Both Obama and McCain have their Supporters and Detractors regarding "Natural Born" status.

Without taking any position; Here is some cogent discussion scholarly written on the topics.

  1. MCCAINS_CITIZENSHIP_AND_CONSTITUTIONAL_MEDTHOD_SPIRO.pdf
  2. MICHIGAN_LAW_REVIEW_FIRST_IMPRESSIONS_VOL_107_1.pdf
  3. ORIGINALISM_AND_THE_NATURAL_BORN_CITIZEN_CLAUSE_Lawrence_B_Solum.pdf
  4. THE_JUSTICIABILITY_OF_ELIGIBILITY_MAY_COURTS_DECIDE_WHO_CAN_BE_PRESIDENT_by_Daniel_P_Tokaji.pdf
  5. WHY_JOHN_MCCAIN_WAS_A_CITIZEN_AT_BIRTH_by_Stephen_E_Sachs.pdf
  6. WHY_SENATOR_JOHN_MCCAIN_CANNOT_BE_PRESIDENT_Chin.pdf
  7. THIS IS QUITE GOOD Legislation Introduced to Remove McCain’s Panama Problem in Seeking Presidency
  8. OBAMA'S FRIENDS
  9.